Wally Tyner amid solar panels on the roof of Purdue's Knoy Hall. (Photo by Tom Campbell)
Chances of Saving with Solar Energy Greater for Indiana Farms than Homes
By Natalie van Hoose - Published March 5, 2015
The probability of saving money by using solar energy rather than standard grid electricity is 92 percent for Indiana farm businesses and about 50 percent
for homes, Purdue University energy economists find.
While current energy policies play key roles in providing incentives for the use of solar energy in Indiana, businesses have an additional cost-saving
option not available to residences: Businesses can deduct their investment in solar from their revenues - a tax policy known as depreciation.
A benefit cost analysis conducted by Wally Tyner, the
James and Lois Ackerman Professor of Agricultural Economics, and graduate student Jinho
Jung showed that if homeowners could also depreciate the cost of installing solar energy systems, their chances of saving with solar would rise to about 90
"Under current law and policy, whether you lose or make money with solar as an Indiana homeowner is like throwing the dice - you don't know," Tyner said.
"But solar is a clear economical choice for farm businesses. The tax advantage from depreciation makes a huge difference in the overall economics."
The use of solar energy, an emissions-free and inexhaustible resource, is expanding as new policies encourage the adoption of renewable energy sources. But
many consumers are uncertain whether it is cheaper to operate and maintain solar energy systems than to buy standard grid electricity, particularly in
Indiana where electricity prices are low compared with many other states. About 95 percent of Indiana's electricity comes from coal power, the cheapest
Tyner said the switch to solar power is hindered by policies that do not put solar on what he and Jung called a "level playing field" with coal power.
In Indiana, three policies provide tax-paying homeowners with incentives for using solar energy: net metering, which allows consumers to sell excess solar
electricity back to the grid; financing through a home equity loan with tax deductible interest; and a federal tax credit for 30 percent of the
installation costs of solar energy systems. Farm businesses can depreciate their investment in solar in addition to these three policies.
Tyner and Jung evaluated how the economics of using solar energy in homes and businesses would change in a scenario in which policies gave solar and coal
power the same treatment. They removed the federal tax credit from solar energy since the credit is not available to coal power companies. They added
depreciation to home solar energy systems since coal power companies can depreciate their building costs and applied a carbon tax to reflect the fact that
solar energy does not emit carbon, unlike coal power.
In this scenario, Indiana farm businesses and homes would have about an 84 percent chance of saving money by generating electricity from solar rather than
"If you put solar energy and coal power on a level playing field, solar emerges as a clear winner," Tyner said. "Many more homes in this state would have
Tyner and Jung's analysis factored in multiple economic variables over 20 years, including the maintenance and repair costs of solar panels, economic
inflation, the annual loan payment from financing, Indiana's climate and uncertainty in electricity prices.
An important finding, Tyner said, was that the analysis showed a carbon tax and the ability to depreciate an investment in solar would give as much
incentive for adopting solar energy as the current federal tax credit does.
Tyner and Jung published a paper on the cost-efficiency of solar energy for Indiana homes in Energy Policy. The paper is available at http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421514004807.
They also authored Economic and Policy Evaluation of Solar Energy for Indiana Business and Residential Application, an Extension publication
comparing the costs of using solar energy in Indiana business and homes. The publication is available for free download from Purdue Extension's Education Store at https://mdc.itap.purdue.edu/item.asp?Item_Number=RE-9-W#.VNJD1UgijnI