Skip to Main Content

Americans on both sides come together over food policy

Polarization has increased over the last two decades, pushing Americans on the left and right of the political spectrum farther apart. But we’ve long set aside our differences to break bread together, and there’s evidence that food is one area in which Democrats and Republicans are actually growing closer politically.

Jayson Lusk
Jayson Lusk

In 2011, Purdue University’s Jayson Lusk measured public opinion related to food policy based on political ideology. He, along with Christina Biedny and Trey Malone from Michigan State University, re-examined those issues in a 2018 survey and found that rather than growing apart, Republicans and Democrats have come closer together in several areas over that time.

“Our results suggest that a widening political rift in the United States is not observed in food and agricultural policy opinions, but rather that partisan voters have become increasingly interventionist,” the economists say in a paper published in the journal Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy. “Concurrently, we find that public opinions in the United States, as a whole, have become more heterogeneous on many food policy issues.”

Americans are looking to the government to ensure the safety of food and promote healthy food, with 75 percent of respondents in 2018 favoring more authoritarian intervention. In particular, respondents wanted more government action to ensure safe food. And 12 percent more 2018 respondents wanted the government to act on ensuring food is healthy.

Trey Malone
Trey Malone

Republicans shifted the most toward increased regulation when it comes to access to organic, local, healthy and affordable food. The only area in which Republicans maintained a belief that less government intervention was necessary was in policies regarding fast food.

“I find that kind of surprising in some ways because more regulation doesn’t tend to be people’s default position on other issues,” said Lusk, head of Purdue’s Department of Agricultural Economics. “Our food system is better than it’s ever been before, but people don’t see it that way. That may come from concerns about food safety and a lack of knowledge about food production.”

Democrats shifted more strongly in favor of government control in the areas of food safety and food technology.

Farmers Market Produce
Despite widening polarization, Democrats and Republicans have come closer together on their political beliefs surrounding access to local foods, according to Purdue University research. (Purdue Agricultural Communication photo)

Republicans and Democrats converged on issues surrounding organic food and local food, driven by changes in Republican opinions. Malone said that makes sense because of how people think about food.

“People tend to be very pro-agriculture, and that means the agriculture they think of the most. That tends to be the nostalgic idea of small farms growing food locally,” said Malone, an assistant professor in MSU’s Department of Agricultural, Food, and Resource Economics. “The local food system, in my mind, has always been a bi-partisan issue.”

Lusk thinks little attention on these issues from the media and politicians likely keeps people from immediately defaulting to a particular party ideology as they might on other issues.

“This is an issue not well-defined by political parties. People don’t know how to answer according to their political intuitions,” Lusk said.

Featured Stories

Students gather at Purdue Summer Science Program on campus at Purdue
Donation takes Summer Science Program to the next level

If you’re on Purdue’s campus in the summer, you may notice a group of students...

Read More
Mary Strickland
Mary Strickland - Graduate Ag Research Spotlight

Mary Strickland is a lifelong animal lover — so much so that she admits to occasionally...

Read More
Ismail Olaniyi flies a UAV up above the trees.
The crossroads between lemon trees and technology

In warmer southern and western states, citrus orchards are important for feeding and bringing...

Read More
A hand holding two eggs
Rehabilitation through agricultural skills with Purdue Farmer-to-Farmer Trinidad and Tobago

Gardening and poultry care are sometimes seen as trendy hobbies in the U.S., but in Trinidad and...

Read More
Joe Ogas, the newly appointed head of the Department of Biochemistry, in his biochemistry lab in Whistler Hall of Agricultural Research
Purdue Agriculture dean selects Ogas as new department head of biochemistry

Bernie Engel, Purdue University’s Glenn W. Sample Dean of the College of Agriculture, has...

Read More
Field with tar spot
Fighting Tar Spot, A New Foe for Farmers

The strange black circles began appearing on corn leaves in Indiana’s Cass and Carroll...

Read More
To Top