August 7, 2025

Comparing Net Returns for Alternative Leasing Arrangements

by Michael Langemeier

Obtaining control of land through leasing has a long history in the United States. Leases on agricultural land are strongly influenced by local custom and tradition. However, in most areas, landowners and operators can choose from several types of lease arrangements. With crop share arrangements, crop production and often government payments and crop insurance indemnity payments are shared between the landowner and operator. These arrangements also involve the sharing of at least a portion of crop expenses. Fixed cash rent arrangements, as the name implies, provide landowners with a fixed payment per year. Flexible cash lease arrangements provide a base cash rent plus a bonus which typically represents a share of gross revenue in excess of a certain base value or threshold. Each leasing arrangement has advantages and disadvantages. These advantages and disadvantages are discussed on the Ag Lease 101 web site. Rather than focusing on the advantages and disadvantages of various lease arrangements, this article uses a case farm in west central Indiana to illustrate net returns to land derived from crop share, fixed cash rent, and flexible cash lease arrangements.

Leasing Arrangements

Net return to land from 2007 to 2025 from a landowner perspective were computed for a case farm in west central Indiana. Information for 2025 was projected using income and cost projections in early August. The case farm had 3000 crop acres and utilized a corn/soybean rotation. Lease arrangements examined included a crop share lease, a fixed cash rent lease, and a flexible cash lease.

With the crop share lease the landlord received 50 percent of all revenue (crop revenue, government payments, and crop insurance indemnity payments). In addition to providing the land, the landowner paid 50 percent of seed, fertilizer, and chemical (herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides) expenses as well as 50 percent of crop insurance premiums. The case farm participated in government programs (e.g., ARC-CO and PLC programs), and purchased 85 percent revenue protection coverage.

Fixed cash rents were obtained from the annual Purdue Farmland Value Survey. Specifically, cash rents for average productivity land in west central Indiana were used. The flexible cash lease arrangement used a base cash rent that was 90 percent of fixed cash rent. In addition to the base case rent, the landowner received a bonus of 50 percent of the revenue above non-land cost plus base cash rent if revenue exceeded non-land cost plus base cash rent. Revenue included crop revenue, government payments, and crop insurance indemnity payments. All cash and opportunity costs, except those for land, were included in the computation of non-land cost. More discussion regarding possible parameters that can be used for flexible cash leases can be found in Langemeier (2018).

Comparisons of Net Return to Land among Leasing Arrangements

Before making comparisons between leases, we will briefly discuss bonus payments for the flexible cash lease. Per acre bonus payments for the flex cash lease arrangement are illustrated in figure 1. During the 2007 to 2025 period, bonus payments were incurred in 11 years. Bonus payments ranged from $0 to $127 per acre, and averaged $37 over the 2007 to 2025 period. From 2007 to 2013, the average bonus payment was $59 per acre. The annual bonus payment from 2014 to 2019 was zero. The bonus payment from 2020 to 2023 averaged approximately $73 per acre. There was no bonus payment in 2024 and the projected bonus payment in 2025 is $0. The largest bonus payment, $127 per acre, occurred in 2021.

Figure 1. Bonus Payments (Per Acre) for Flex Cash Lease Arrangement

Figure 1. Bonus Payments (Per Acre) for Flex Cash Lease Arrangement

Pairwise comparisons were used to compare the three leasing arrangements. Figure 2 compares the crop share lease to the fixed cash rent lease. The landowner net return for the crop share lease was more variable. As would be expected, net return for the crop share lease increased faster when revenue was increasing, but also decreased more rapidly when revenue was declining. With the exception of 2009, the net return for the crop share lease was higher than the net return for the fixed cash rent lease from 2007 to 2012. From 2013 to 2019, the net return for the crop share lease was from $44 per acre (in 2019) to $132 per acre (in 2015) below the net return for the fixed cash rent lease. On average, from 2013 to 2019, the net return for the crop share lease was $70 per acre below the net return for the fixed cash rent lease. From 2020 to 2022, the net return for the crop share lease was from $1 to $74 higher than the net return for the fixed cash rent lease. The average difference during the 2020 to 2022 period was $42 per acre. The net return for the crop share lease was $31 and $69 per acre lower than the net return for the fixed cash rent lease in 2023 and 2024, respectively. Due to relatively high input costs and relatively low crop prices, the net return for the crop share lease is projected to be $131 per acre lower than fixed cash rent in 2025.

Figure 2. Comparison of Net Returns for Crop Share Lease and Fixed Cash Rent Lease  (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowners)

Figure 2. Comparison of Net Returns for Crop Share Lease and Fixed Cash Rent Lease (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowners)

Figure 3 compares the net return for the flexible cash lease to the net return for the fixed cash rent lease. This graph looks remarkably similar to figure 2. Net returns for the flexible cash lease were more volatile than the net returns for the fixed cash rent lease. The net return for the flexible cash lease was relatively higher in 2007-2008, 2010-2012, and 2020-2022. During the 2007 to 2013 period, the average net return for the flexible cash lease was approximately $12 higher than the average net return for the share rent lease, and $38 per acre higher than the average net return for the fixed cash rent lease. From 2014 to 2019, the annual net return for the flexible cash rent lease was on average $26 per acre below the net return for the fixed cash rent lease. However, it is important to note that during this same period the net return for the flexible cash lease was $49 per acre higher than the net return for the crop share lease. From 2020 to 2022, the net return for the flexible cash lease was $68 per acre higher than the net return for the fixed cash rent lease and $26 per acre higher than the net return for the crop share lease. In 2023 and 2024, net returns for the flexible cash rent lease was approximately $18 and $28 lower than net returns for the fixed cash rent lease, respectively. A bonus payment is not expected in 2025, so the net return for flexible cash rent is expected to be lower than the net return for the fixed cash lease.

Figure 3. Comparison of Net Returns for Flexible Cash Lease and Fixed Cash Rent Lease  (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowner)

Figure 3. Comparison of Net Returns for Flexible Cash Lease and Fixed Cash Rent Lease (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowner)

Differences between the fixed cash rent lease and the other two leasing arrangements are illustrated in figure 4. This chart was created by subtracting fixed cash rent payments per acre from the net return for the flexible cash lease and the net return for the crop share lease. As noted above, the net returns for the flexible cash lease mimic those for the crop share lease. However, from a downside risk perspective, the flexible cash lease did not decrease as rapidly as the crop share lease from 2013 to 2015, and from 2023 to 2025. The net return for the flexible cash rent lease has been relatively higher than the net return for the crop share lease since 2012.

Figure 4. Differences Between Fixed Cash Rent Lease and Other Lease Arrangements (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowner)

Figure 4. Differences Between Fixed Cash Rent Lease and Other Lease Arrangements (Per Acre Net Returns for Landowner)

What about differences in the potential net returns for the three crop leases in 2026? Early projections for 2026 show a potential bonus for the flexible cash rent lease of $0. The crop share lease is also projected to have lower net returns than both the fixed cash rent lease and the flexible cash rent lease. Continued high input prices and relatively low crop prices are adversely impacting potential net returns for crop share and flexible cash rent leases. Of course, the projections for 2026 are sensitive to income and cost budget assumptions.

Summary and Conclusions

This article used a case farm in west central Indiana to compare the net return to land for crop share, fixed cash rent, and flexible cash leases. The average net returns to land from a landowner perspective were similar among the three lease arrangements. The flexible cash lease mimicked the ups and downs of the crop share lease. However, the upward and downward spikes for the flexible cash lease were less pronounced than those for the crop share lease. Choosing among the leases depends on a landowner’s desire to capture improvements in crop share revenue and ability to withstand downside risk. The crop share and flexible cash leases allow landowners to more fully capture annual improvements in crop revenue, but also increase the probability of downward movements in annual net returns.

 

 


References

Ag Lease 101, www.aglease101.org/, accessed July 21, 2025.

Langemeier, M. “Flexible Cash Lease Comparisons.” Center for Commercial Agriculture, Purdue University, Department of Agricultural Economics, August 2025.

TAGS:

TEAM LINKS:

RELATED RESOURCES

2025 Cash Rental Rates

September 10, 2025

Purdue ag economists Todd Kuethe and Michael Langemeier discuss Indiana farmland cash rental rates on this, the second of two episodes reviewing the 2025 Purdue Farmland Values and Cash Rental Rates survey results. The survey shows Indiana cash rents continue to rise by about one and a half percent. The episode shares historical trends in cash rents, and how cash rents compare to share and flex lease rents, regional differences, net returns to land, and the increasing interest in flexible cash leases from both landowner and tenant perspectives.

READ MORE

Crop Net Return Prospects, Presentation at Pinney Purdue Field Day

August 20, 2025

Michael Langemeier presented at the Pinney Purdue Field Day in Wanatah, Indiana on August 20, 2025, on crop net returns and the farmland market.

READ MORE

Farmland Prices Increase Despite Downward Pressure, Purdue Ag Econ Report August 2025

August 19, 2025

Indiana farmland prices have continued the trend of record highs in 2025, according to the latest Purdue Farmland Value and Cash Rents Survey results. The average price of top-quality farmland reached $14,826 per acre, a 3.0% increase from June 2024. Statewide, cash rents increased from 1.5 to 1.7% for poor-, average-, and top-quality land.

READ MORE

UPCOMING EVENTS

Purdue Flexible Lease Workshop

September 16 at 7 pm or September 23 at 9 am

The Flexible Lease virtual Workshop, presented by the Purdue Extension Land Lease Team, will include a presentation and discussion to help you decide if a flexible land lease arrangement is right for your farm.

Read More

2026 Crop Cost and Return Guide

September 16, 2025

The 2026 Purdue Crop Cost and Return Guide provides estimated costs and net returns for planting, growing, and harvesting corn, soybeans, and wheat in the upcoming year. Cost and return information presents information for low, average, and high productivity soils. Early projections point to slightly higher breakeven prices.

READ MORE

2025 Farmland Values & Market Trends

September 9, 2025

Purdue ag economists Todd Kuethe and Michael Langemeier as they discuss Indiana farmland values on this, the first of two episodes reviewing the 2025 Purdue Farmland Values and Cash Rental Rates survey results. The survey shows Indiana land prices continue to rise and are anticipated to continue a modest increase for the rest of 2025 for most of the state.

READ MORE

Farmland Prices Increase Despite Downward Pressure, Purdue Ag Econ Report August 2025

August 19, 2025

Indiana farmland prices have continued the trend of record highs in 2025, according to the latest Purdue Farmland Value and Cash Rents Survey results. The average price of top-quality farmland reached $14,826 per acre, a 3.0% increase from June 2024. Statewide, cash rents increased from 1.5 to 1.7% for poor-, average-, and top-quality land.

READ MORE