What would Thanksgiving look like without Indiana?

Imagine a cornucopia of Thanksgiving goodness--pumpkin pie, cornbread, stuffing, flaky bread rolls--all flanking the culinary linchpin: the turkey. Without Indiana much of this bounty would not be readily available at Thanksgiving or, indeed, any other time of the year.

“It is hard to imagine a Thanksgiving meal that doesn’t have some ties back to Indiana agriculture,” Jayson Lusk, department head and distinguished professor of agricultural economics, said. “Indiana is a top ten agricultural producer in the U.S.”

thanksgiving-illustration-for-web-03-panorama1.png

Indiana is also a top five producer of several Thanksgiving staples. Indiana is second in the nation in egg production, fourth in pumpkins and turkeys and fifth for corn grain and hog production. The state is also a major dairy producer, with an estimated 187,000 dairy cows. Green beans, tomatoes and sweet corn, commonly found in favorite holiday side dishes, are also specialty crops grown throughout Indiana. The diversity of Indiana’s farming profile is actually rooted in one of the lesser known legacies of the pilgrims.

“One interesting component of the Thanksgiving story you don’t often hear about is that when the pilgrims first arrived they started farming with community owned plots,” Lusk said. “That didn’t work out so well because there were no incentives for individuals to work hard when it didn’t directly benefit them. This is sort of where our bountiful food system came from because it forced people to experiment on their own plots and figure out what gave them a comparative advantage. In a way, the story of Thanksgiving is really one of free enterprise.”

Thanksgiving is a great holiday, Lusk continued, because it elevates so many different dishes, offering farmers an incentive to diversify their crops, which is beneficial economically and ecologically. Knowing that Thanksgiving always brings with it certain gastronomic demands means farmers can confidently grow more specialty crops like pumpkins.

“One of the signals of a healthy diet is a diversified diet,” Lusk said. “I think the Thanksgiving meal represents that diversity both for consumers and producers.”

Featured Stories

A dark tornado funnel is shown near a farm.
2025 Top Midwestern weather events

From floods to fall drought to 20-foot icicles, the Midwest experienced some record-breaking...

Read More
A landscape view of Pfendler Hall, one of the three buildings that houses faculty and staff from Purdue Forestry and Natural Resources.
FNR Honors Four Individuals for Department Service in 2025

The Purdue Department of Forestry and Natural Resources has honored four individuals for their...

Read More
the Szymanski and Siegmund labs stand together in front of photos and models of leaf epidermis on a screen between them.
Sticking together under stress: NSF grant brings plant biologists and engineers together to discover how tissues stay connected

Daniel Szymanski, professor of Purdue’s Departments of Botany and Plant Pathology and...

Read More
Ag Barometer
Farmer sentiment drifts lower as trade uncertainty hangs over agriculture

Farmer sentiment dipped slightly in December, with the Purdue University/CME Group Ag Economy...

Read More
Photos from the top 2025 stories for Purdue College of AG
What people clicked, watched and read in 2025

Explore the top content from 2025 for the Purdue College of Agriculture.

Read More
Wildlife alumna Lauren Wetterau kneels next to a red squirrel midden in the Greater Yellowstone ecosystem; a red squirrel sits on downed tree
Alumna Lauren Wetterau's Research Featured on Animal Planet Show

2023 wildlife alumna Lauren Wetterau is coming to a television screen or streaming service near...

Read More