June 30, 2019

Assessing Risk Management Skills

As farms continue to consolidate it becomes increasingly important to assess a farm’s management skills. At a certain farm size, it is no longer easy or feasible for the manager or managers to wear every management hat. How does the management team determine when to focus on professional development, delegate management tasks among mangers, and seek outside assistance? This is the seventh article in a series of articles pertaining the assessment of management skills. The topic of this article is the assessment of risk management skills.

Relationship Management and Leadership Skills

Table 1 presents important risk management skills. Important skills in this management area include the following: managing production, financial, human, legal, and relationship risks; developing written contingency plans to deal with uncertain events; maintaining proper levels of life, health, property, and liability insurance; carefully selecting crop insurance products and coverage levels; documenting compliance with regulatory requirements; effectively managing interest rate risk; and having written estate and succession plans in place. Each farm operator should rank their ability with respect to each skill using a 1 to 5 scale with 1 be relatively weak and 5 being relatively strong with respect to that skill. The idea behind checklists such as that presented in table 1 is to assess whether a farm has a skills gap, which is defined as the difference between skills that a farm needs and the skills of their current workforce (operators and employees). Conducting a skills gap analysis helps a farm to identify skills that will be needed to become more efficient and expand.

Table 1. Risk Management Skills

The checklist in table 1 does not include a final tally score, nor does it address tradeoffs in various skill or ability areas that may lead to success. Rather, the checklist helps farm operators evaluate their skills and abilities in areas critical to long-term financial success. As farm operators fill out the checklist, they should try to determine which of the skills listed are most essential to improving efficiency and expansion plans.

The discussion below will focus on the steps commonly using when managing risk and the identification and classification of risks. Taxonomies that categorize risks often exclude discussions of strategic risk which involves the sensitivity of the farm’s strategic direction and ultimate vulnerability and sustainability of the farm to uncertainties in the business climate. A brief discussion of strategic risk can be found below. More information regarding strategic risk can be garnered from a previous article (here).

Steps in Risk Management

Crane et al. (2013) discuss nine steps involved in risk management planning. We will briefly review these steps. The first step is to identify and classify risks (see discussion below). The second step is to measure or assess risks. Variability of outcomes and downside risk (i.e., the likelihood of low outcomes) are two common measures of risk. Risk can also be assessed using scenarios. For example, when developing a business plan it is common to evaluate three scenarios: most likely, worst case, and optimistic. The third step is the assess risk bearing capacity, which is directly related to a farm’s liquidity and solvency position. A farm with strong working capital and solvency positions, can take on more risk. The fourth step is to evaluate risk tolerance or preferences. Risk averse individuals are cautious risk takers. They often give up some income to mitigate risk. Risk neutral individuals focus on income potential when making decisions. The fifth step is to set risk management goals. The sixth step is to identify risk management tools such as crop insurance, forward pricing, controlling leverage, and reducing the chance of a disease outbreak with preventive measures. The seventh step is select professional assistance in management areas where the expertise does not reside within the business. The finals two steps involve making a decision, implementing the plan, and evaluating the results.

Identifying and Classifying Risks

The five primary sources of risk include production risk, marketing risk, financial risk, legal risk, and human risk. The first three sources are largely self-explanatory. Tools used to mitigate these risks include crop insurance, futures and options, and managing liquidity and solvency. Legal risk may emanate from contracts, business organization, and laws and regulations. Human risk includes the following categories: human health and well-being, family and business relationships, employee management, and transition planning. Obviously from the list, even farms without hired employees (i.e., just utilize family labor) face human risk.

Strategic risk involves the sensitivity of the farm’s strategic direction and vulnerability and sustainability of the farm to uncertainties in the business climate (Boehlje and Langemeier, 2017). Strategic risk can also be thought of as the source of loss that may arise from the pursuit of an unsuccessful business plan. Managing strategic risk often requires the development of alternatives or contingency plans. Using what-if scenarios can be useful. In addition to thinking about the possible consequences of a major decision, it is also important to think about how difficult it may be to unwind a decision if does not go according to plan.

Concluding Comments

There is an important tradeoff between risk and return. Activities or investments with a higher expected return involve higher levels of risk. Similarly, activities or investments with lower levels of risk are often associated with lower expected returns. Risk management involves optimizing expected returns given the risks involved. In addition to managing production, marketing, financial, legal, and human risk, it is imperative that a farm assess and manage strategic risk. Strategic positioning skills and strategic risk will be the topic of the next article in this series.

Citations

Boehlje, M. and M. Langemeier. “Assessing and Managing Strategic Risk.” Center for Commercial Agriculture, Purdue University, May 2017.

Crane, L., G. Gantz, S. Isaacs, D. Jose, and R. Sharp. “Introduction to Risk Management: Understanding Agricultural Risks.” Extension Risk Management Education and Risk Management Agency, 2013.

TEAM LINKS:

PART OF A SERIES:

RELATED RESOURCES

Farm Resilience, Management Practices, and Producer Sentiment: Segmenting U.S. Farms Using Machine Learning Algorithms

April 4, 2024

Margaret Lippsmeyer, Michael Langemeier, James Mintert, and Nathan Thompson segment U.S. farms by farm resilience, management practices, and producer sentiment. This paper was presented at the Southern Agricultural Economics Meeting in Atlanta, Georgia in February. 

READ MORE

Key Resources Determining the Future of the Farm: Human Capital & Information Technology

April 4, 2024

This article emphasizes the significance of human resources and information technology (the ability to manage and analyze data) as we transition into a new era of production agriculture. This new era brings further innovation of agricultural technology, information processing, and use of artificial intelligence to digitize agriculture.

READ MORE

Integrated Risk Management: Developing an Asset-Based Business Strategy

March 15, 2024

Integrated risk management is a comprehensive approach that addresses business, financial, and strategic risks collectively, safeguarding your organization against potential threats. This article analyzes the importance of integrated risk management for production agriculture, an industry which is highly susceptible to external shocks.

READ MORE

UPCOMING EVENTS

We are taking a short break, but please plan to join us at one of our future programs that is a little farther in the future.

2024 Crop Cost and Return Guide

November 22, 2023

The Purdue Crop Cost and Return Guide offers farmers a resource to project financials for the coming cropping year. These are the March 2024 crop budget estimations for 2024.

READ MORE

(Part 2) Indiana Farmland Cash Rental Rates 2023 Update

August 7, 2023

Purdue ag economists Todd Kuethe, James Mintert and Michael Langemeier discuss cash rental rates for Indiana farmland in this, the second of two AgCast episodes discussing the 2023 Purdue Farmland Values and Cash Rents Survey results.

READ MORE

(Part 1) Indiana Farmland Values 2023 Update

August 6, 2023

Purdue ag economists Todd Kuethe, James Mintert and Michael Langemeier discuss Indiana farmland values on this, the first of two AgCast episodes discussing the 2023 Purdue Farmland Values and Cash Rents Survey results. Each June, the department of agricultural economics surveys knowledgeable professionals regarding Indiana’s farmland and cash rental market.

READ MORE