Skip to Main Content

Mayflies' Reaction to Pollutants Differs by Population

Mayflies riverIn toxicology, there is an assumption that all populations of species are the same. A recent study by graduate research assistant D. Riley Rackliffe and associate professor of vertebrate ecology Jason Hoverman aimed to test that assumption and found dramatic variation in how mayfly (Heptageniidae) populations reacted to pollutants.

“We often look at species as homogeneous across their range, aka, a mayfly from one creek in Michigan is the same as a mayfly from Indiana so long as they are the same species,” Rackliffe explained. “This is particularly important in how they respond to pollution. This study demonstrates that populations of the same species from different places responded differently to the same pollutant. So, you can't just find out what amount of pollution one population can handle and assume all other mayflies are equally tolerant to it.”

Mayflies
In fact, Hoverman and Rackliffe’s research found that mayfly sensitivity to neonicotinoids, an agricultural insecticide, may vary as much as 6.5 times between different mayfly populations.

“Whether the variation in pesticide tolerance is the result of inherent differences in the populations or an evolutionary response to pesticide exposure is an open question in mayflies,” Hoverman notes.

Regardless, this research has far reaching implications especially to those responsible for assessing the toxicity of pesticides, as pesticides must be assessed regarding potential damage to the environment as part of the licensing process.

“As part of this process they test it on various organisms to see how toxic it is,” Rackliffe said. “This (study) demonstrates that we could be underestimating the environmental risk of pesticides if our test organism comes from unusually tolerant populations. It also has implications for people concerned about water quality as we often use mayflies as "canaries in the coal mine" to tell us if a body of water is polluted. What if the canaries (the mayflies) are evolving greater tolerance to the pollutants?”
Mayflies
The study, which seeks further explanations regarding variation in responses to pesticides, is at the heart of Rackliffe’s research. It also builds upon other studies that have found variation in pesticide tolerance in other organisms like frogs.

“Understanding why some populations tolerate exposure to pesticides while others are heavily impacted may allow us to preserve biodiversity that might otherwise be lost,” Rackliffe added. “This could be done by establishing appropriate pesticide-free refuges, carefully monitoring the amount of pesticides used, or creating ways to keep pesticides from leaving the target areas (fields) and entering non-target habitats (creeks).”

Read Rackliffe and Hoverman’s paper “Population-level variation in neonicotinoid tolerance in nymphs of Heptageniidae in Environmental Pollution’s October 2020 issue. The abstract is available here: Population-level variation in neonicotinoid tolerance in nymphs of the Heptageniidae

Featured Stories

Elena Boughton holds a bird while bird banding; Elena holds a snapping turtle at Summer Practicum; Elena sits atop a mountain in Costa Rica.
Meet FNR Outstanding Junior Elena Boughton

Wildlife major Elena Boughton has been selected as FNR’s Outstanding Junior for 2024-25....

Read More
Portrait of Jingjing Liang, forestry and natural resources professor, taken in the Envision Center with tree collage background.
Jingjing Liang named 2025 University Faculty Scholar

When Jingjing Liang, an associate professor in the Department of Forestry and Natural Resources,...

Read More
cows in a field
Food products from animals with heritable genetic modifications potential boon to producers, consumers and animals

Farmers have been improving the genetics of their animals for thousands of years through...

Read More
Anna Paltseva, clinical assistant professor of urban science in the agronomy department, sits outside of a greenhouse, holding her Urban Soils Guide.
Framework to expand engagement in urban areas

Urban soils are essential to building sustainable cities — from supporting green...

Read More
Ag Barometer
Farmer sentiment improves as long-term optimism outweighs tariff concerns

Farmer sentiment improved in April as producers expressed more optimism about current and future...

Read More
black soldier fly
Revolutionizing waste: How black soldier flies transform food waste into sustainable solutions

With food waste being a growing problem around the world, finding innovative solutions is more...

Read More
To Top